High Court orders Muni to eradicate illegal dumpsites


The current by-laws and waste management system in Makhanda have been declared unconstitutional, and Makana Municipality must eradicate seven specific illegal dumpsites within 14 days.

This historic ruling was made in a court order upheld by the high court in Makhanda on Thursday 9 September on behalf of the Ezihagwini Street Committee and Mary Waters High School, who took the Makana Municipality to court for its failure to remove refuse and to put an end to illegal dumpsites in parts of the town.

The municipality agreed to the court order, which requires it to clean up the seven illegal dumpsites in the city’s poorer areas. The court order also ruled that the municipality work with communities to identify all other illegal dumpsites within 30 days and then clear all illegal dumpsites within 120 days.

The municipality must also provide three plastic bags to each household weekly and produce a comprehensive audit of Makhanda’s waste management needs. Once identified, these needs must be addressed no less than three months following the completion of the audit.

Speaking on the steps of the High Court after the victory, Ezihagwini Street Committee member Mxolisi Mtshima said the committee would follow up on the specifics and timeframes for the Municipality to respond to all the areas covered by the court order.

Ezihagweni Street Committee member Mxolisi Mtshima speaks on the steps of the High Court after the historic victory. Photo: Phetolo Phatsibi

“We are happy with the court’s ruling. We will communicate the outcome with the community specifically to those affected areas in the community,” Mtshima said.

“We are willing to assist in other operations such as cleaning campaigns, but we need the municipality to respond because they have a key role to play in assisting those initiatives,” he added.

The Ezihagwini Street Committee was represented by the Legal Resources Centre (LRC), who welcomed the comprehensive court order.

LRC attorney Cameron McConnachie said, “Our clients look forward to reclaiming a living space that is not an affront to their dignity or their constitutional right to an environment that is not harmful to their health and well-being.

“We are under no illusions – this is going to be a long process and will require a vigilant community and dedication from municipal officials. We will be monitoring the process closely,” McConnachie said.

The main areas affected by the Municipality’s failures are the Joza, Fingo and Tantyi townships. Extension 6 has become known by residents as Ezihagwini (pigsty).

The main areas affected by the Municipality’s failures are the Joza, Fingo and Tantyi townships. Graphic: Legal Resources Centre

The Ezihagweni Street Committee cited the legal right of all citizens to a clean and safe environment, which is currently not possible in Makhanda given the illegal dumpsites, some of which are close to schools.

McConnachie said for the past three years, residents have worked tirelessly to have the Makana Municipality fulfil its obligations in terms of refuse collection and ensuring that the environment they live in meets the legislative standards of an environment that is safe and free from any hazards.

“We are pleased that the court has put residents’ needs first in this matter.”

The rights that are being infringed by the Makana Municipality’s inability to manage illegal dumpsites in the city. Graphic: Legal Resources Centre

A summary of the demands made by the Ezihagweni Street Committee in their successful High Court action against the Makana Municipality. Graphic: Legal Resources Centre.


Facebook Comments

About Author

Comments are closed.